Mafia #25

Happy wrote:

Since we're not doing anything I'm just gonna go ahead and lynch vote tundra until he comes back

Counter lynch. Lynch Happy

T-thanks bro ;__;

What's the odds that he's gonna read the previous page before deadline? lmao

YUS THE CHURCH WON!!! Lol it was a pretty sure thing we were gonna win once mafia, oh I mean, "government agents" decided not to kill

Hahahaha this was a pretty excellent game! I'm really sad that people didn't comment more though, it got STUPID quiet towards the end of the game.

Lol my choices were pretty unfortunate from the start! SO GLAD I went with recruiting Michael instead of Happy! Might've actually lost the game then! Man, I was fully trying to send mind vibes to my cult peoples when I died going "READ THE NIGHT STORY YOU FOOLS! IT SAID TWO PEOPLE KILLED ME!! HAPPY HAS A PARTNER!!!!!!" That obviously didn't work the way I wanted, but hey, we still won

Btw mod, how did you decide the ordering of the actions? I was the one that recruited Screaming, and government chose to kill me. What made you decide to make the recruitment go through first?

Thee_Slushee wrote:

Man, I was fully trying to send mind vibes to my cult peoples when I died going "READ THE NIGHT STORY YOU FOOLS! IT SAID TWO PEOPLE KILLED ME!! HAPPY HAS A PARTNER!!!!!!" That obviously didn't work the way I wanted, but hey, we still won

I just realised that as I was reading through the government chat file. I totally forgot about the fact there were two of them...

Those chat docs and the mod planning doc had me cracking up. Seeing things from the other side's perspective (or things for how they really are) is not only enlightening but sometimes hilarious.

I had this big "HAHA! The Cabbage God Cometh!" speech written out but got ninja'd by the night phase announcement. I knew I was going to die come night anyway.

GG all.

GEE GEEEEEEEE

LAUNCHES SELF INTO ABYSS, ALL MY META WAS WRONG

GEOFF DON'T EVEN REMIND ME ABOUT "THE KILL IS BENEVOLENT"


CONRAD I'M GOING TO THROW YOU UNDER THE BUS NOW, WHY DID WE KILL JONNO
imagine if we no-kill'd first night.. then pushed lynch on chanisha...... imagine...........
(to be fair yass, I'm awful at pushing lynch XD but how to convince people when it's like:

• them: change your win condition so your prev. was irrelevant; allows team communication in a game where information is paramount
• us: literally murderers)

Gr88888 job @ michael especially, more than merely 'not suspecting' you, you literally radiated townie to me all game AND @ TELESTOMP FOR THE MOST YOLO ROLECLAIM THAT STARTED OUT GREAT, THEN BECAME AWFUL, THEN IF WE'D GONE ANY FURTHER INTO THE GAME IT WOULD'VE LOOPED BACK TO INCREDIBLE AGAIN

Geoff I hope it's clear I loved your concept to death esp. being inserted into a role of ambiguous morality, which is oh-so-painfully-reminiscent of real life. So yanno I just had to get all into it. GLORY TO THE EMPIRE


If I can offer any critique it's that, well yanno, as the losing team, first I think we were underpowered
NO SERIOUSLY I think that the biggest problems lay with the non-affliated 'survivor' townies, who had nothing to do besides be inducted >: I mean look at joce who sort of potato'd all game. Then again she potatos a lot of games. .__.
It's largely to do, sadly, with the ambiguity that made the setup so neato; when you're given the least information, it helps to have a clear direction to push in, and that direction comes from the clearly-defined 'good' and 'evil' of the default flavour. I think joce summed it up best when she said "we can't tell whether we're winning or losing" - who I assume was referring to role reveal, but also, it's sort of indicative of how she had no incentive to play at all.

Moreover is probably what does sound like a "baww I lost bawww" argument - I guess this is a problem with cult as a whole: they can win by sitting around and doing nothing *__* So tele and I were playing people left and right (am I overestimating? Did you guys just lol at us and sip your coffee? XD) and it didn't matter an iota in the end. I guess that's what happens when you give cult essentially-infinite recruiting power, but I don't think it's v fun for them if cult leader just dies >: so I don't know

OVERALL though the shape that the game took in retrospective is gr8 gr8 gr8! thank you geoff for your kool game modding
[hi 5s telestomp again for being an incredible, not-mafia partner]

Also, there's one moment in that cult doc which I really want to doodle. So maybe you will see that in a day or so. xD

Tehehehe the mafia doc is pretty great! Oooh keen to see which cult leader part you're drawing! Is it the part of me climbing back into my grave?

Man, I actually had a feeling Tele was trolling about cop. But I fully hand it to you, that was a pretty successful cop claim for the most part!

Hehehhe mod notes are hilarious too! Lol it actually is super funny how I DIDN'T get lynched day 1. That honestly has to be one of my personal mafia victories, worming my way out of that! XD

LOL and YES SCREAMING! Y u vote to extend day when you know we pretty much had it in the bag? XD

The logic I assume most people followed that day was the same as michael's - in a tossup between (proposed) cult and mafia, you gotta be with the cult <W< Plus real world logic probably takes over for a while - "guys with guns" = dangerous ;__;
But yes, I bet jonno would've helped cement that lynch!

I've been meaning to say, I'm sorry that these games have ended up triangulating you what, three threads in a row. xD


Anyway, can't nobody say I never did nothing for the peoples:

Spoiler:

HAHAHAHAHHA THAT IS THE GREATEST DOODLE!!! Can this please happen in every game? XD

Glorious

Yeaaaah, this potato totally picked up on absolutely nothing.
Now I feel silly for not reading between the lines.

/sees chanisha's new avatar, spits out water

More doodles depends on if we have more events worth doodling ; )

@Joce I think I said on skype, but you were the single person with absolutely no personal leads, so I don't blame you XD

FINALLY getting around to reading this thread since victory!!!

Was a fun game.

Thee_Slushee wrote:

LOL and YES SCREAMING! Y u vote to extend day when you know we pretty much had it in the bag? XD

To keep my goodie good townie image Voting night is for evil people remember. I was already acting out of character by choosing no lynch. And I was even town at that point too.

Happy wrote:

The logic I assume most people followed that day was the same as michael's - in a tossup between (proposed) cult and mafia, you gotta be with the cult

This was my thinking pretty early on. I'm surprised no one realised I was almost asking to be recruited for a while. When I said that cult can technically help town win and not lynching Slushee, I was fully trying to get cult to recruit me. Hahaha. As a bonus, the rest of town could/would agree and then they would help us kill the mafia standing in our way.


BAHAHAHAH!!! Happy that image! Glorious.

Please please please mod a game with images.

O.O Uhhhhhhh.....I said I'd consider... But I actually have zero plan as of now, haha. I guess I could maybe throw something together, but I know nothing so it probably won't be all that exciting.

I would also approve of a doodle comics based game